Studio 5 - Weekdays at 11am on KSL 5

Being the "Perfect" Mother

In the quest to be better, sometimes women get sidetracked with the quest to be perfect.

Allyson Reynolds with the website "Power of Moms" defines what the "perfect mother" really looks like.


Let's admit it, ladies. Sometimes we can get a little too obsessed with perfection: Perfect body, perfect hair, perfect outfit, perfect children, perfect dinner, perfect schedule, and (of course) a perfectly clean and organized home. Then we look at reality and wonder why we feel frustrated and depressed: Flabby tummy, thinning hair, outdated clothing, rebellious children, cereal for dinner, impossible schedule, and a house that is far from clean and organized.

The sad but funny thing is, we spend an inordinate amount of time and energy trying to reach this elusive state of perfection, feeling vaguely dissatisfied as long as we fall short, but never asking if our definition of perfection is even remotely realistic!

For better orQ: At for worse, all of us come into motherhood with some sort of picture in our minds of what a "perfect mom" looks like. These images (and the expectations that go along with them) may come from our family of origin, our culture, or even our faith. And while many of these images and expectations can be good and even motivating, the problem comes when we try to do and be more than is humanly possible when considering our personalities and unique life situations.

In our effort to stamp out perfectionism, let's take a humorous look at some of the mythical moms that exist in our own culture:

First we have Picture-Perfect Mom. Despite giving birth to six children, she is a firm and muscular size 2. This mother's make-up never wears off and her hair doesn't frizz. Her children are always well groomed, even stylish. She has a professionally manicured lawn and her home is beautifully decorated, annoyingly clean. She can find any household item in 15 seconds flat because "there is a place for everything and everything is in its place." Her mini-van smells like vanilla.

Next is Practice-Makes-Perfect Mom. All her children play several instruments and excel at sports. Her family can organize a string quartet or a basketball team at the drop of a hat. This mother can't see out of the back window of her car from all the "student of the month" bumper stickers. Scholarships dot the horizon. This mom is currently taking classes in French and fencing while getting her masters degree in child psychology.

Then there is Perfect-Timing Mom. Her household runs on a very tight schedule. She exercises, does laundry and starts dinner before the kids leave for school. She never misses an appointment, is always on time, and lives by her planner. She has trained her children to dutifully check off their chore charts and complete all required after-school responsibilities before they engage in "free time". Calendaring is a weekly family activity.

Last but not least is Practically-Perfect-in-Every-Way Mom otherwise known as The Perfect 10. This mother possesses all the aforementioned skills, traits and talents and then kicks it up a notch: she's a Martha Stewart! She cooks, sews, gardens and cans. (All organic, of course.) She clips coupons and cuts her own children's hair. She can get chocolate out of cashmere while balancing her checkbook, and has created more original "pins" on Pinterest than humanly possible. This mom has endless patience and wisdom. She is everyone's best friend. Her children come to her with their problems, and she lives without regrets.

What do all these mothers have in common? They aren't real! (Isn't that a relief?) And yet their images live on in the minds of far too many mothers, taunting them when they are already feeling far too inadequate.

As a self-proclaimed Frustrated Perfectionist turned Recovering Perfectionist striving to be a Calm and Contented Realist, let me share with you five suggestions for stamping out the perfectionist in you.

1) Change your definition of perfection.

I am a firm believer that perfection is more of a spiritual state than a physical one. Unfortunately, I think most of us gravitate toward physical perfection because it's easier to see, manipulate, and control. It's so easy to get wrapped up in the world of physical beauty and the manufactured perfection we see in the hundreds of images thrown at us every day. But is that really where we want our focus to be?

For example, which is more important to you-to have a clean and clutter-free home, or a clean and clutter-free mind and heart? To make your outer appearance stylish and beautiful, or to radiate inner beauty? To help your children excel in school and extracurricular activities, or to teach them the values of honesty, self-control, and compassion?

Of course both important, but I've often wondered about the message I am sending to my own children. While I'm all about trying to help them succeed in the world and improve their talents, I don't want them to feel like their value lies in looking good, keeping their bedrooms spotless, and getting straight A's. And as long as we continue to use "perfect" as a description of things that can be easily photographed or quantified, most of us will come up lacking.

In my own experience, I have a much greater sense of peace and joy in my work as a mother when I take some of the time, money, and energy that might otherwise go to trying to make everything look perfect, and invest it in areas that are truly meaningful--ways that contribute to how my home feels. And maybe that's the take-way: It's not about how your home looks, but how it feels.

2) Be your own kind of "perfect" mother.

One of the easiest traps we fall into as mothers when we're obsessing over this false ideal of perfection is that of comparing ourselves to other mothers.

The truth is, we're not in the same boat, just the same ocean. Comparing each other's boats and constantly keeping track of who is ahead does nothing to get us where we are trying to go; it only distracts us from the care of our precious cargo.

We can't all be Type A mothers. We all bring different gifts to the altar of motherhood. What matters is our children, not our egos, and it doesn't do our children any good to compare our weaknesses against someone else's strength.

Be your own kind of "perfect" mom. That will mean something completely different for you than it will for the mother down the street. And that's a good thing! Life is so boring when we all try to be the same.

Anna Quindlen said it best: "The thing that is really hard, and really amazing, is giving up on being perfect and beginning the work of becoming yourself." The irony of this statement is that if you do "become yourself" you will be perfect because you will be who you were created to become. And that person and that life may not look anything like your previous definition of perfect.

3. Focus on striving, not arriving.

I like to think of the word "perfect" as a verb, not an adjective. To perfect means to improve, refine, hone, or work on. That's a lot less pressure than trying to "be" perfect today, right now. It's that whole "joy in the journey" thing that we often find difficult to master as mothers. (I'm not the only one, right?) To think of perfection as an unfinished, lifelong process is something each of us can do every day without a deadline or a flawless end product to measure up to.

I find this quote from Harriet Braiker to be so true: "Striving for excellence motivates you; striving for perfection is demoralizing." Isn't it interesting how we constantly tell our kids to just do their best, but we don't offer ourselves the same kindness? We would do well to remember in our crazy, daily lives as mothers, perfection really is more about striving than arriving.

4. Realize that perfection comes through imperfection.

Why do we try so hard to attain an unrealistic standard of perfection when in fact it is the imperfections of our lives that actually perfect us? What do I mean? Think about it: The child with the illness or disability that teaches us how to really pray or sacrifice; the difficult teenager who pushes us to dig deeper and love more. The daily grind that forces us to get more organized and disciplined. The financial struggles that keep us humble and motivate us to reach out to and help others struggling in similar ways. You see?

The definition of mothering is to look after, care for, protect, nurse, and tend. That's messy work! And there is nothing in that definition about alphabetically organized spice racks, Disney cruises, multiple degrees, or granite counter tops. Have you ever noticed that children don't care if your middle is mushy or there are cobwebs in the corner? Their needs are very basic and you are at the top of their list.

Read these inspiring words from Leonard Cohen:

Ring the bells that still can ring

Forget your perfect offering.

There is a crack in everything,

That's how the light gets in.

In other words, embrace your perfectly imperfect life and let it work its magic!

There are more than enough years in this (hopefully) long life to have things just so and to live a life of tidy orderliness where things happen at their appointed times and without interruption. (Doesn't that just sound wonderful?) But now is not the time for that. Now is the time to bask in the fistful of muddy dandelions, the sloppy kisses, and the giggles under the messed up covers. That's my kind of perfection.

Maybe the last time I had tight abs was when I was nine months pregnant, and I have never seen the bottom of my "special issues" laundry basket, but every day I try my best to make sure my kids feel loved, happy, secure, and capable of meeting the challenges of life.

I know I am on the right track when I'm snuggling in bed with my precious little 5-year-old daughter and she puts her arms around me and says, "You're the best mom in the whole universe!" No matter what else I did or didn't do that day, I'm pretty sure at that moment, I am the perfect mom.


Allyson Reynolds

Allyson is the mother of four children, Kate, Will, Elizabeth, and Rachael. She has lived 27 of her 30 something years in the Midwest (Iowa and Illinois), but has also lived in San Diego, Florida, Utah, Japan and Los Angeles. She and her husband, Brandon, recently moved from his childhood home near Los Angeles to the rather uncharted territory of Utah.

Allyson earned a B.A. in family science from Brigham Young University and met her husband while living in Sendai, Japan as a missionary. When she can get a little "me time" (what's that?) she enjoys reading and blogging, the great outdoors, cooking, digital scrapbooking, getting things done, living like a tourist, and date nights with her husband.

Surviving nine years of her husband's medical training in Iowa while raising their first three children provided many award-winning memories such as shoveling snow and cutting grass with a baby on her back, and cleaning out the gutters on the roof of their house while pregnant. For her, the hardest part of motherhood is finding balance—and not just on the roof. She loves being a mom the most when she finds that "sweet spot" between getting things done and letting the less important things go so she can be in the moment before the moment is gone. For her, snuggling up with her kids and a good book is pure bliss. Allyson blogs at A Day in the Life.

Leave your comments...

comments powered by Disqus